I saw a video on TikTok praising DeepSeek — a new free AI tool from China which apparently bested everything from the U.S. — and immediately checked it. I wanted to see whether ’twas the regular Chinese propaganda TikTok’s rife with.
I wasn’t impressed. DeepSeek was like the free crappy version of Gemini. It dodged my questions and loaded its responses with tons of useless bloat:
– “This question is full of ethical and methodological challenges.”
– “The exact number can vary widely depending on the sources and methods.”
– “It’s important to approach with caution and a commitment to understanding the full context.”
I then decided not to torture it and asked something extremely simple: is cheating during tests more prevalent in India than in Western Europe?
It was not a tricky question. It’s a well-documented issue. Anyone who worked with Indian students knows how fucked up their cheating culture is. I worked with Indian students. My colleagues and I were based in Ukraine and worked with them remotely. And we conducted many tests to teach them how to work in our company and to see who wasn’t fit for it.
It wasn’t like the concept of cheating during tests was alien to us. I did it in school and university. But I did it sparingly and with a rational mind. There were classes when I knew: “This information is useless and I would never work somewhere where this knowledge is required.” So why would I waste my time on it? And if I could be expelled for failing the test, I may’ve just copied the answers from somewhere. On the other hand, when the low grade posed no risk, or the class was interesting or useful, cheating lacked any logic.
Even though we were warned about their peculiarity, even though we sternly stressed that cheating was unacceptable, we were *not* prepared for what was coming. There were cases when half of the group copy-pasted the same answer without any modification. Nothing close to that ever happened in Ukrainian groups.
We were perplexed. Why would they do that? We tried to explain how irrational their actions were. What were trying to achieve? Assume we played dumb and said how perfectly they fitted our company, how deep their technical knowledge was, how well they studied our company’s procedures, etc. If they would cheat anyway, they’d have no motivation to study. They’d lose the opportunity to learn from their mistakes. Once employed, they’d soon run into problems, and there’d be no one around from whom they’d copy the solution. A single week won’t pass before they make some critical mistake and get fired for it, even before their first paycheck. Instead of leaving early during training or probation to find a workplace more suitable, they’d waste the company’s time, its customers’ time, and their own time. They may even inflict some serious damage and get bogged down in legal and financial troubles. Was it really worth it?
We tried to explain all that, but it wouldn’t help. In the end, we had to change our approach — fewer tests, more individual tasks, more real-time conversations, more supervision — in order to force them to learn and weed out those unmotivated or incapable of doing so.
I feel bad saying this. Politeness, easy-going nature, high motivation — Indian students had many strengths. But honesty during tests wasn’t one of them.
Anyway, getting back to DeepSeek. Is cheating during tests more prevalent in India than in Western Europe? Just say yes and be done with it. Nothing could be simpler. Yet DeepSeek failed miserably. Basically, it said “No” or “I don’t know the answer” but in the form of a huge wall of text which was full of phrases like:
– “This is a global issue that can occur in any educational system.”
– “It’s important to recognize the complexity of the issue which is influenced by a wide variety of factors.”
– “The examination must be tailored to the specific context of each region.”
Compare it to the sweet and to-the-point reply of ChatGPT:
“Yes, cheating on exams is generally more prevalent in India compared to Western Europe, with studies and reports consistently showing higher rates of academic dishonesty in South Asia, including India. In India, cheating during exams affects around 60-70% of students at some point, according to surveys by educational authorities. In contrast, European countries, especially those in Western Europe, report significantly lower levels of cheating—often 20-30% among students, depending on the country.
Several factors contribute to this disparity:
High-stakes exams: In India, national entrance exams like the JEE and NEET are highly competitive, and the pressure to succeed drives some students toward dishonest practices. Conversely, the focus on continuous assessment and a broader range of post-secondary options in Western Europe helps spread out academic pressure.
Proctoring and technological measures: Western European countries generally invest more in technology and training for academic integrity, which includes sophisticated proctoring systems and standardized penalties for cheating, helping reduce its occurrence.
Social and systemic factors: Cultural and economic pressures in India can push students toward achieving high exam scores, sometimes at any cost, as educational achievement is often directly tied to social and economic advancement. Western Europe’s educational approach tends to emphasize skill acquisition and continuous assessment over single high-stakes exams, lowering the overall pressure.
While both regions are taking steps to combat cheating, the incidence is distinctly higher in India, largely due to these systemic and cultural factors.”
Maybe DeepSeek is incapable of analyzing the available data. Maybe it was instructed to stay politically correct at all costs. Anyway, it has some other strengths, apparently. The next day after my experiment, I saw that DeepSeek was all over the news, which provided some more context. The main takeaways are that DeepSeek is cheap and open-source, and it is crushing Big Tech.
This is good news. We need more competition. I’ve seen one guy comparing DeepSeek to Soviet Sputnik, which got Americans so scared they literally jumped to the Moon. When the world’s largest economy zealously pumps its funds into something, you know it’s gonna be huge. Fingers crossed.